Jonathan Moyo

Professor Jonathan Moyo is a political scientist and MP for Tsholotsho North (Zanu PF)

Calling Bennett ‘murderous Selous Scout’ not racist

By Jonathan MoyoPolitics Last updated on: November 27, 2009
200 CommentsComment on this article

DOES criticising Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s controversial choice of Roy Bennett as Deputy Minister of Agriculture amount to raising the sceptre of racism against whites?

 

In the same vein, is it racist to merely remind those among us with short or treacherous memories that Bennett is a former member of the Rhodesian Selous Scouts who served in the similarly murderous Rhodesian infantry, whose indisputable agenda was to entrench the ideology of white supremacy over blacks by torturing, maiming and killing freedom fighters while terrorising and subjugating blacks in this country in the vain hope of defeating the liberation struggle?

 

These and other related questions have come to the fore of national debate following the publication by the Zimbabwe Independent newspaper of a racially motive article, "Moyo raising the sceptre of racism" (November 13 to 19) authored by one Liberty Bhebhe.

 

While the article itself did not contain anything worthy of a response or comment, its packaging and layout betrayed what could be interpreted as a despicable attack on free speech in the interest of public debate.

 
The article in question purported to be a rejoinder to a recent contribution made by this writer to the Financial Gazette and the New Zimbabwe.com website which categorically and unapologetically maintained that Tsvangirai’s nomination of Bennett as Deputy Minister of Agriculture is an unacceptable insult to our country’s liberation struggle and the legacy of national independence.
 
In packaging that article, the Independent astonishingly inserted Bennett’s picture with a scandalous caption that said "Roy Bennett … Persecuted for being white".
 
This was contrasted with a picture of this writer which was outrageously captioned "Moyo … Takes refuge in racism".
 
In the circumstances, the title of the article and the captions of the pictures that were inserted in it were arguably defamatory and thus beneath the high standard of fair and balanced media coverage which has come to be associated with the Independent, an otherwise leading newspaper.
 
It is preposterous in the extreme for anyone to suggest that recalling Bennett’s undeniable membership of the murderous Selous Scouts as a Rhodesian infantryman is tantamount to racism.
 
Just how does a fact, even if disgusting, become racism? Is there anyone out there who does not know of the wicked atrocities and massacres that were committed by the Rhodesian infantry and Selous Scouts in Zimbabwe and in the refugee camps in Zambia and Mozambique during the liberation struggle?
 
With the obvious answers to these questions in mind, it is clearly outrageous for anyone to claim that this writer was "taking refuge in racism" when he strongly objected to Prime Minister Tsvangirai’s nomination of Bennett as a Deputy Minister of Agriculture, and when he warned of dire electoral consequences for the MDC T should that nomination succeed given Bennett’s unacceptable background as a former active member of the Rhodesian infantryman and Selous Scout whose toll of combined massacres and atrocities is yet to be fully appreciated.
 
For the sake of perspective, it is important to note that while this newspaper’s racially emotive packaging of the story in question might be an isolated editorial incident, it is nevertheless a telling example of an emerging and orchestrated MDC T propaganda ploy whose treacherous purpose is to brand by definition as "racist" anyone who criticises former Rhodie whites who, like Bennett, hold key and very influential positions in the MDC T.
 
The fact that there are many more Rhodies behind the MDC T, who are very influential as fundraisers and not as officeholders, makes this propaganda trick even more sinister.
 
It is also notable that, with the author of the article in question as a case in point, virtually everyone from the MDC T who has written on the Bennett issue uncritically defending white Rhodies and attacking this writer has an Ndebele surname.
 
Of course people are who they are, or perhaps even who they say they are. But a well documented Selous Scout tactic is to create pseudo events — such as fake violence that is typically blamed on opponents — and the use of crude propaganda penned by Rhodies and peddled by their tribal puppets under ethnically convenient pseudonyms.
 
There’s more to be revealed soon about this unfolding ethnic strategy with its origins in Rhodesia. It seems that just like Rhodesians say they never die, they think the same is true of their dirty tricks like manufacturing pseudo political violence and using ethnic pseudonyms in the media to peddle revisionist propaganda whose not-so-hidden import is that white Rhodesia was better than black Zimbabwe.
 
Arguably, there is a context to this and it is that, as the twist of history would have it, the same international powers that supported the illegal and racist Rhodesian regime are now actively supporting former Rhodesians in the MDC T, such as Roy Bennett, and they are presenting these Rhodies not only as human rights victims of Zimbabwe’s historic land reform that was launched in 2000, but also as the new champions of democracy in our country.
 
This is the essence of the so-called Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act (Zidera) whose lead sponsor was the late US Senator Jessie Helms, who unashamedly distinguished himself as a rogue stalwart of the Rhodesian racist cause before and after this country’s heroic independence in 1980.
 
It is not a coincidence that, within the Zidera scheme of things, the struggle for democracy in Zimbabwe is supposed to have started in June 2000 when Zimbabweans embarked on the Third Chimurenga which also happened to be the time when Rhodies like Bennett thought they could form or join the MDC T and use it to stop the historic land reform programme with the support of the same Europeans and Americans who did not support Zimbabwe’s liberation struggle in the first place.
 
But the record shows that the 2000 land reform programme was not stopped. No wonder there have been spirited efforts to shift the MDC T paradigm from stopping the programme to reversing it. Bennett is supposed to be the MDC T’s point man for the reversal, to benefit former white farmers with their roots in Rhodesia.
 
This is why the MDC T and its sponsors want him to be inside what they cynically call "the belly of the beast" as deputy minister of agriculture whom they believe has the Selous Scout ruthlessness and motive to derail and subvert the historic land reform programme from within the coalition government in the Rhodesian interest.
 
There is nothing racist about pointing this out or making the argument that, as a former member of the Rhodesian Selous Scouts, Bennett is not suitable to serve as a minister of any kind in any government in independent Zimbabwe.
 
Indeed, to expect Bennett to serve as a government minister in Zimbabwe today is as unacceptable as having somebody like the notorious apartheid killer Eugene de Kock serving as a government minister in President Jacob Zuma’s ANC cabinet.
 
In the end, it is instructive that those who claim that such arguments are racist are also the same self-righteous elements who claim to be the champions of free speech and democracy as if they are unaware of their sickening double-standards. The time has come to expose these elements for the charlatans that they are.
 
Moyo is MP for Tsholotsho North [Zanu PF]
Print Print this article Share Share this article Email Mail this article
Tags: farm invasions, jonathan Moyo, land reform, liberation war, racism, rhodesia, roy bennett, selous scouts, Zimbabwe
← Older Comments
  • chibwechitedza

    Moyo tinyararire kachihure kepolitics, u dont represent the masses bt u and Mugabe. Pple voted 4 u as an indep (if they wanted Zanu PF, they cld have voted 4 Zanu PF) but u betrayed that mandate when u re-joined Zanu. Its not abt u bt the pple u represent. if you want to dig into history u will find that there are more pple (black and white) who shed more blood than u are alleging Benet did. there is nothing u will ever say that pple will take serious, even if u use all e books in the world, ndiani angateerera kapfambi ke politics. u r not a man of your word!! u claim that Zanu killed bt i think u are lying

  • chibwechitedza

    Moyo tinyararire kachihure kepolitics, u dont represent the masses bt u and Mugabe. Pple voted 4 u as an indep (if they wanted Zanu PF, they cld have voted 4 Zanu PF) but u betrayed that mandate when u re-joined Zanu. Its not abt u bt the pple u represent. if you want to dig into history u will find that there are more pple (black and white) who shed more blood than u are alleging Benet did. there is nothing u will ever say that pple will take serious, even if u use all e books in the world, ndiani angateerera kapfambi ke politics. u r not a man of your word!! u claim that Zanu killed bt i think u are lying

  • Wezhira

    That’s what you see when you look at life with tinted glasses proffethor. Some of us take the broader picture and we see the good and the ugly in far more people than you do. We won’t be blinkered to think that it’s good for a whiteman to kill but “not-so-bad” for a blackman to kill. You and me know of many people with bloody hands in today’s govt starting from Mugabe himself and down to to the militia.
    It’s ugly though you might wish they were more saintly. In a freer society, some documentary evidence might be required to verify your story. Asizve tiri mu jungle rinohi Zimbabwe: a ruined country surrounding the Great Zimbabwe Ruins

  • Wezhira

    That’s what you see when you look at life with tinted glasses proffethor. Some of us take the broader picture and we see the good and the ugly in far more people than you do. We won’t be blinkered to think that it’s good for a whiteman to kill but “not-so-bad” for a blackman to kill. You and me know of many people with bloody hands in today’s govt starting from Mugabe himself and down to to the militia.
    It’s ugly though you might wish they were more saintly. In a freer society, some documentary evidence might be required to verify your story. Asizve tiri mu jungle rinohi Zimbabwe: a ruined country surrounding the Great Zimbabwe Ruins

  • Sosore

    You all seem to loose the point and focuss on destructive arguments. That is why Zimbabwe will take years and years to move on: its people like all of you. You can not discuss facts. Shame

  • Sosore

    You all seem to loose the point and focuss on destructive arguments. That is why Zimbabwe will take years and years to move on: its people like all of you. You can not discuss facts. Shame

  • rodney

    I agree with the Professor for once. Roy Bennet has a bad record just like ZANU PF. He killed black zimbabweans for the record I lost relatives through these Selous Scouts. By being a member of MDC does not really make Mr Bennet an angel overnight. As we will soon be arresting some ZANU PF leaders for cimes against Humanity I think Mr Bennet has a case to answer !!!

  • rodney

    I agree with the Professor for once. Roy Bennet has a bad record just like ZANU PF. He killed black zimbabweans for the record I lost relatives through these Selous Scouts. By being a member of MDC does not really make Mr Bennet an angel overnight. As we will soon be arresting some ZANU PF leaders for cimes against Humanity I think Mr Bennet has a case to answer !!!

  • Lloyd

    Proffesor
    Once you decide to tell the world who is who in Zimbabwe politics, tell who are you first. We are aware that you are the brains behind 2000 killikngs by ZANU PF aslo aftyer March elections you are the person who made the blue print for all the madness we saw. You have planned and kiiled more Zimbabweans than all wjo were killed by all selous scouts combined though out. Gukurahundi killed more people that those killed during the liberation struggle. Proffesor where were you during the war of liberation, i was in a war zone i saw magandanga achiponda vanhu vachifa more than Rhodesian soilders.
    Olivia Muchena akaenda nembatya dzakauraya Vanhu Kumozambique Handizvi here nhai mai muchenma rambai tinzwe kana zvisizvo. jonathan You went to school came back schooled but not educated. You are an educated fool you have no wisdom.

  • Lloyd

    Proffesor
    Once you decide to tell the world who is who in Zimbabwe politics, tell who are you first. We are aware that you are the brains behind 2000 killikngs by ZANU PF aslo aftyer March elections you are the person who made the blue print for all the madness we saw. You have planned and kiiled more Zimbabweans than all wjo were killed by all selous scouts combined though out. Gukurahundi killed more people that those killed during the liberation struggle. Proffesor where were you during the war of liberation, i was in a war zone i saw magandanga achiponda vanhu vachifa more than Rhodesian soilders.
    Olivia Muchena akaenda nembatya dzakauraya Vanhu Kumozambique Handizvi here nhai mai muchenma rambai tinzwe kana zvisizvo. jonathan You went to school came back schooled but not educated. You are an educated fool you have no wisdom.

  • mpho

    Zimbos i feel that your victory is around the corner,most of the comments shows that if you were given transparent chance to cast your votes,the likes of Moyo and his dictator friend would be history.We Southern africans have never allowed our past to control our future,thats why the ndebeles have never revenged the misery of the 80,s,ANC,MANDELA etc so why now when we live in a global village do we want to base our arguments on THE COLOUR of the skin.A problem for Zimbabwe is a problem for Southern Africa fact,a peace for Zim will bring stability to SADC.We know that in SADC region before this crisis you were the most educated of all even Bob. Education liberates but with the likes of Prof and Mugabe it has not liberated them but mislead them.I wait for that day when ZIM will return to its glory day.Let the people decide not war veterans, not the police, not jona moyo, not hiding behind the west n the old song of sanctions.

  • mpho

    Zimbos i feel that your victory is around the corner,most of the comments shows that if you were given transparent chance to cast your votes,the likes of Moyo and his dictator friend would be history.We Southern africans have never allowed our past to control our future,thats why the ndebeles have never revenged the misery of the 80,s,ANC,MANDELA etc so why now when we live in a global village do we want to base our arguments on THE COLOUR of the skin.A problem for Zimbabwe is a problem for Southern Africa fact,a peace for Zim will bring stability to SADC.We know that in SADC region before this crisis you were the most educated of all even Bob. Education liberates but with the likes of Prof and Mugabe it has not liberated them but mislead them.I wait for that day when ZIM will return to its glory day.Let the people decide not war veterans, not the police, not jona moyo, not hiding behind the west n the old song of sanctions.

  • Batshele Nduna

    Please help me? Are you people sure Bennett was a Selous Scout? Or is it because he served in the Rhodesian Forces and therefore hewas a Scout? For all I know Selous Scouts had a lot of Bllack people who would pose as terrorsts.Are all Shonas Gukurahundis as the unit was mainly made up of Shonas? Let us be objective. Stop thinking like children!! Mature!!!

  • Batshele Nduna

    Please help me? Are you people sure Bennett was a Selous Scout? Or is it because he served in the Rhodesian Forces and therefore hewas a Scout? For all I know Selous Scouts had a lot of Bllack people who would pose as terrorsts.Are all Shonas Gukurahundis as the unit was mainly made up of Shonas? Let us be objective. Stop thinking like children!! Mature!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KB3KCO4Z5JSIISMYBVJ257QDRY Donald Chihota

    This is a stupid argument Professor…Roy Bennett can not be compared to the notorious apartheid killer Eugene de Kock. Can you relate a single incident in which Roy Bennett killed someone. You are a very big idiot…I doubt your professorship because your arguments are totally flawed.

  • Pingback: psychic on line

  • Pingback: hire thermal imaging camera

  • Pingback: What Is The Best Yeast Infection Treatment

  • Pingback: {Legalsounds|Download music}

  • Pingback: which kitchenaid mixer

  • Pingback: rest homes

  • Pingback: psychic readings

  • Pingback: site

  • Pingback: nz boats for sale

  • Pingback: screen doors nz

  • Pingback: View my website to watch spongebob

  • Pingback: tahoe weather

  • Pingback: new zealand advertising

  • Pingback: drains unblocking

  • Pingback: equipment rental

  • Pingback: Hampton Bay Solar Lights

  • Pingback: free clairvoyant readings

  • Pingback: Watch Contraband Online

  • Pingback: auckland lighting

  • Pingback: Lab supplies

  • Pingback: http://forums.miniclip.com/member.php?281551-seantorres32

  • Pingback: led watches

  • Pingback: led grow lights

  • Pingback: Swiffer Coupons

  • Pingback: http://www.sharynkopf.com/index.php/member/21357

  • Pingback: acid reflux symptoms

  • Pingback: porno darmo

  • Pingback: ICDC College linkedin updates

  • Pingback: cat scan vs mri

  • Pingback: true nutrition coupons

  • Pingback: Tresore BKH Sicherheitstechnik ist Spezialist für mechatronische Schließsysteme, Schließanlagen, Zutrittskontrolle, Einbruchmelde- u. Videoüberwachungsanlagen, Rettungswegtechnik, Rauchwarnsysteme, Alarmierungssysteme sowie Briefkastenanlagen und Tres

  • Pingback: Locksmith Toronto

  • Pingback: http://www.artslant.com/ew/groups/show/469876

  • Pingback: New Jersey Scholarships For Minorities

  • Pingback: Buy Cisco

← Older Comments