24 May 2012
 
New Zimbabwe Header
Zuma painting difficult to ban: judge
Zambian held over 22 jumbo tusks
'Gay world' against nature: Mugabe
Cyanide killers get death penalty
MORE NEWS
Gono bans Zimplats from local banks
RioZim targets Murowa Diamonds takeover
MORE BUSINESS
Video: Decibel drops Dancehall Style
'Unpatriotic' Roki gets axe warning
MORE SHOWBIZ
Kutsanzira double spurs on CAPS
Hoffenheim loan out Musona
MORE SPORTS
Why Zuma's Spear should stay up
Zuma painting an attack on blacks
MORE OPINION
 
Facebook: reward for innovation
MORE COLUMNISTS
 

Mujuru evidence 'compromised': expert

02/02/2012 00:00:00
by Phyllis Mbanje
 
Hearing ... Vice President Mujuru leaves court on Thursday
 
RELATED STORIES
Mujuru was a ‘tough husband’: Mugabe
Mujuru family demands inquest results
Mujuru lawyer blasted by coroner
Mujuru exhumation request rejected
Mugabe at Mujuru post mortem, inquest told
Mujuru 'unidentified before burial'
Mujuru: family wants second opinion
Mujuru: ZESA rules out electric fault
Arson 'likely cause of Mujuru fire'
Mujuru's flaming body had 'blue glow'
Mujuru’s body found in flames
Mujuru wanted police guards fired
Mujuru considered sleeping in car
Mujuru ‘shocked’ by security lapses
Mujuru passenger, gunfire mystery
Mujuru ‘not drunk’, inquest told
Mujuru inquest opens on Monday

THE handling of evidence at the scene of an August 16, 2011, farm fire which killed Vice President Joice Mujuru’s husband fell below professional standards, a South African forensic analyst told an inquest in Harare on Thursday.

Poor packaging of exhibits from Ruzambo Farm in Beatrice where former army commander General Solomon Mujuru was found burnt to death may have compromised results of forensic tests, said Seomyatseng Jack Maine of the South Africa Police Service.

Maine tested several items recovered from the scene to see if any accelerants were used, and he told an inquest into Mujuru’s death that he had found no such evidence, although that was not to say any were not used.

“There are a number of factors that could compromise quality of results. These include collection method of debris at the scene and also how it was packaged,” Maine told the inquest which is in its third week of sitting.

"The amount of heat is also critical in that if it is extreme, it could actually wipe out all traces of fire accelerants,” he said, adding that there were professional standards that needed to be observed for the most accurate results.

Maine said the exhibits which contained debris from the fire were packed in ordinary plastic bags, a situation which could have compromised the final results.

Asked if that was the ideal packaging, he said the forensic profession emphasised the use of metal containers that have not been corroded or oven bags similar to the ones used in most households for baking.

"It is possible that the packaging may have compromised the results and also the amount of heat they were exposed to,” he testified.

Maine, who was the 34th witness in the inquest, said they had received the exhibits on September 23, 2011, and among the debris were pieces of cloth, ashes and cotton wool.

Another South African expert who testified was Dumisani Portia Chauke, who is also a forensic analyst in SAPS.
 
Chauke was part of the team that performed the DNA test using the late General’s tissue and his daughter's blood.

Chauke said after the analysis, their findings were that paternity was 99,90 which was way above the standard 99,80 proving that the two were father and daughter.

Mujuru’s family has openly criticised Zimbabwean police for clearing his body for burial on August 20 last year, even as DNA tests were yet to be conducted to prove that the charred remains found at the scene of the fire were that of the former Zanu PF power broker.



Advertisement

The last witness for the day was Lieutenant Colonel Kgotlakgomang Ariel Lenong, who is the Chief Forensic Analyst within SAPS.
 
Lenong said his instructions upon receiving the exhibits from the fire were to check for the presence of explosives.
 
His analysis ruled out any presence of explosives.

Meanwhile, South African pathologist Dr Reggie  Perunel – whom the Mujuru family are keen to see take the stand if the presiding magistrate grants an application made last week – was present throughout Thursday’s hearing.

The Mujuru family lawyer Thakor Kewada could be seen constantly consulting with him.

Coroner Walter Chikwanha said he may allow Dr Perunel to be called to the stand after the evidence of Dr Gabriel Alviero, the Cuba-born pathologist who performed the initial post mortem.

The inquest continues on Friday.


 
Email this to a friend Printable Version Discuss This Story
 
Share this article:

Digg it

Del.icio.us

Reddit

Newsvine

Nowpublic

Stumbleupon

Face Book

Myspace

Fark
 
 
 
 
 
RSS NewsTicker