16 January 2017
   
New Zimbabwe Header
Justice Malaba blasts judiciary corruption
War vet decomposes, no money for burial
I ensured land grab rule of law: Chief Just
Typhoid: Residents blast health minister
Physical education exams soon – Minister
Mugabe dying this year pastor arrested
SA: Zuma daughter wants hubby's riches
Govt approves 7km Byo water pipeline
MORE NEWS
No festive cheer for Zim's Delta
South Africa: Ford recalls 4000 cars
MORE BUSINESS
SA: Zim’s urban stars to rock Durban
George Michael's death linked to drugs
MORE SHOWBIZ
Esrom upbeat about Warriors' prospects
AFCON: DR Congo edge Morocco 1-0
MORE SPORTS
The emergence of a post-fact world
Every generation must fight its own demons
MORE OPINION
 
Ambitious Goba: Part gay but all human
Mashizha: telling our own stories as we see them
MORE COLUMNISTS
 
 
Lawyers: Chikurubi escape bid ‘foolish’
01/03/2012 00:00:00
by Phyllis Mbanje
 
Fortress ... Chikubi Maximum Security Prison
 
RELATED STORIES
Prison conditions dire, no water for 10 yrs
Govt denies prisoners starving to death
No money to deport foreign ex-convicts
Zimondi denies prisons overcrowded
Escaped 'child killer' back in jail
Minister barred from prisons visit
Child killer, 2 others in prison break
Khami prison has no doors: report
MDC-T senator wants sex toys for prisoners
Guilty verdicts in prison break trial
30 toddlers jailed with their mums: minister
Guard helps prisoner escape to settle debt
No condoms for inmates: prisons boss
Byo death row inmates denied appeals
Elephant meat for prisoners
Red Cross withdraws prison food aid
Prisoners in Xmas escape
Prisoner’s intestines hang out in court
4 jail guards 'die in training'

LAWYERS representing two men convicted for trying to escape from Chikurubi Maximum Prison have asked the court to be lenient saying the “foolish and amateurish” attempt was made out of desperation.

Albert Matapo and Lucky Mhungu were last Monday found guilty of trying to stage a dramatic break from the country’s most secure prison on April 4, 2010.

Matapo was on remand facing treason charges at the time while Mhungu had been in prison for a while.

But arguing in mitigation ahead of sentencing, the pair’s lawyer Charles Varara urged clemency saying the escape bid was clearly a “mission impossible” adding his clients acted out of desperation.

"No grown man would have managed to go through that small hole any way so it is clear that there was no premeditation it was purely instinctive,” Varara told the court during Thursday’s hearing.

"It should also be noted that first accused (Matopo) was not even supposed to be in jail and second accused (Mhungu) had been in jail for a while and these circumstances prompted the two to act foolishly so the court should be lenient in that regard."

Varara said Matopo harboured some political ambitions which would not have been helped by further incarceration and urged the court to give the pair suspended sentences of no more than three years each.

However, prosecutor Michael Reza said escaping from lawful custody was a serious offence and giving the pair suspended sentences would undermine the judicial system.

"The general public will lose confidence in the justice system if we treat this case lightly,” he said.

"They should get the maximum for this charge of 7 years so that a clear message is sent to other prisoners."

Regarding Matopo’s political ambitions, Reza said the country could do without leaders who do not respect the law but agreed that the escape bid was foolish because accused Chikurubi is a fortress.

"They should first finish their current sentences and then serve for jail breaking otherwise they will not feel the punishment," he added.

The magistrate is expected to hand down sentence on Friday.


Advertisement


 
Email this to a friend Printable Version Discuss This Story
Share this article:

Digg it

Del.icio.us

Reddit

Newsvine

Nowpublic

Stumbleupon

Face Book

Myspace

Fark
 
 
 
comments powered by Disqus
 
RSS NewsTicker