20 April 2014
   
New Zimbabwe Header
Majongwe unleashes lawyers on Mudede
Independence celebration in pictures
Govt risks failing to pay workers
Govt to tighten mines control, fight graft
Opposition in denial over poll rout: Ncube
Indigenisation: Nhema urges clarity
Mugabe speaks to the BBC
Renamo nears deal on joining army
MORE NEWS
Re-engagement key to recovery
Chidhakwa calls for economic reforms
MORE BUSINESS
Tuku defers greatest hits concert
Willom Tight unleashes Ndewangu video
MORE SHOWBIZ
Sundowns suffer Billiat blow
FC Platinum lift Independence trophy
MORE SPORTS
Zimbabwe @ 34, a sad introspection
Zims see nothing to celebrate @ 34
MORE OPINION
 
Zimbabwe at 34, the naked facts
Time to reflect on the gains of independence
MORE COLUMNISTS
 
 
Zuma denies Mugabe rift claims
 

SADC facilitator ... President Zuma meets Tsvangirai, Mutambara and Mugabe
13/12/2012 00:00:00
by David Smith I The Guardian
 
Comrades in arms ... Jacob Zuma and Robert Mugabe
 
RELATED STORIES
Sticking with Zuma suicidal for ANC
Zuma 'can't change direction of Titanic'
Zuma drops cartoon lawsuit
Zuma pays for wives’ keep: spokesman
Jacob Zuma to marry a sixth time
Zuma's Security Council Debate speech
Under-fire Zuma pledges ANC revival
Guilty verdict in Zuma whisky spill assault
Zuma motorcade victim files suit
Zuma sues over Zapiro cartoon
Zuma fires seven ministers
Zuma, Malema square off over succession
Zuma’s fiancee expecting second child

IS LIBERATION blood thicker than democratic water? In his biography, At the Deep End, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai tells how he was "stunned" by South African president Thabo Mbeki's part in a "conspiracy" to divide and weaken the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).

It is also now a footnote in history that when Julius Malema, then president of the African National Congress youth league, turfed a BBC journalist out of a press conference, he had been extolling the virtues of President Robert Mugabe and mocking the "Mickey Mouse" opposition for using air-conditioned offices.

Such incidents illustrate how many in the ANC still see Mugabe as a brother in Africa’s liberation struggle while dismissing the MDC as a Johnny-come-lately conjured up by western imperialists.

Mbeki's successor, Jacob Zuma, is however broadly seen as less sympathetic to Mugabe and more neutral in his mediation efforts ahead of elections expected next year.

Sitting down with Zuma at the Union Buildings in Pretoria, I put to him bluntly: what went wrong in Zimbabwe? He demurs: "I avoid being judgmental to other people."

Many have described Mugabe as a dictator, but Zuma pointedly avoids the word. "I wouldn't because in Zimbabwe Zanu PF holds its conferences, they elect Mugabe; I don't look at how that happened.

“They regularly hold elections and that's why you could say these elections did not go very well. What else do you need? People do things in different places in different ways.

"If you are telling me there have never been elections in Zimbabwe, either in the ruling party or the general election, it would be a different story. How Zimbabweans are influenced in one or the other is a different matter."

Malema, who has visited Mugabe like an apprentice to a master, reportedly claimed that Zuma “hates” Africa’s oldest leader.

Zuma denies this, saying of their personal relationship: "It's good. We were freedom fighters together, we know each other from way back. So I've known him for a long time."

Does that mean Mugabe receives preferential treatment? "Not necessarily. I deal with issues as they come as an ANC and as an individual.

“What we need in Zimbabwe is to ensure that Zimbabwe is democratic, that's why we talk to all of them, let the Zimbabwean people decide which party leads them. We can't interfere."



Advertisement

And what of this notion that the MDC is a stooge of British and American interests? "We don't say that in the ANC.

“Much as it is true that we come from the liberation movement with Mugabe, but that to us does not give anyone a licence to mishandle his country, so if at all there was mishandling of the country we'd be critical.

"We don't say because a person has come from not a liberation movement, they cannot be democratic. What determines everything is how people run their affairs in their own countries.

“We are not going to prefer them in terms of their history, but we are going to prefer them in terms of what they do.

"However, the history will remain the history: the fact that I was a freedom fighter together with Mugabe is a fact we cannot erase. We must judge what people do at a given time."


 
Email this to a friend Printable Version Discuss This Story
Share this article:

Digg it

Del.icio.us

Reddit

Newsvine

Nowpublic

Stumbleupon

Face Book

Myspace

Fark
 
 
 
comments powered by Disqus
 
RSS NewsTicker