20 August 2014
   
New Zimbabwe Header
Rushwaya held over Magaya extortion
Bufallo Range airport in sorry state: official
Chitungwiza suspends 100 for striking
Release ‘Cash-gate’ audit reports: TZI
Byo farm seizures: Zapu warns Mugabe
CIO operative jailed for killing cyclist
Passports rush as economy dives
Zimbabwean in comma after UK attack
MORE NEWS
British firm to inject $27m into SeedCo
Zimplats closes mine, expects $100m hit
MORE BUSINESS
Drummer stars at Belfast festival
Carl Joshua Ncube cancels some shows
MORE SHOWBIZ
ZPC Kariba in crushing first loss
Highlanders hike charges for Triangle
MORE SPORTS
ZimAsset and the related politics
Women and children not their concern
MORE OPINION
 
SADC: Zim must use chairmanship to shine
Econet, Padenga: Stars in our firmament
MORE COLUMNISTS
 
 
South Africa gripped by politics of nostalgia
31/03/2012 00:00:00
by Eusebius McKaiser
 
Looking back ... President Zuma and former President Mbeki
 
RELATED STORIES
Blair ‘plot’ drove military to Mugabe
UK invasion: why it should have happened
Blair denies plotting Mugabe military ouster
NewsDay suspends editor over Mbeki
Mbeki anger over UNISA lecture 'lies'
Transcript: Mbeki on Zim polls, land reform
Mbeki's diamond conference speech
Mbeki troubled by 'directionless' SA
Africa's future and international law
Mbeki on Egypt, Tunisia and Libya
Mbeki best ever ANC leader: Malema
MDC-T says Mbeki had 'role' in split
Tsvangirai and McGee: Tendi replies to MDC
Tsvangirai and McGee: MDC statement
Tsvangirai sought US advice in GPA talks: Mbeki

IN SOUTH Africa, the latest political fad is being down on President Jacob Zuma and high on his predecessor Thabo Mbeki.

Nostalgia for former President Mbeki is washing over South Africa these days. A book about his presidency by the civil servant who ran his office sold out before it even hit the shelves last week. Weeks earlier, a prominent Sunday newspaper had boldly asserted on its front page, “Mbeki Is Back.”

But all this interest in Mbeki, who was in power from 1999 to 2008, is really about disinterest in the current president, Jacob Zuma. It’s about concerns that Zuma might be reelected as president of the African National Congress later this year, which would pave his way to a second term as South Africa’s president in 2014.

Zuma’s critics — like the leadership of the A.N.C. youth wing led by Julius Malema and trade unionists who think the A.N.C. is not being sufficiently pro-worker — aren’t even hoping for Mbeki’s return: the Constitution prohibits him from serving another presidential term, and he doesn’t seem very interested in heading the A.N.C. again. They are probably trying to make room for another candidate, like the current deputy president, Kgalema Motlanthe.

This may seem like garden-variety politicking and positioning, and it is. But it’s also a kind of mythmaking that dangerously distorts historical truths and undermines any honest evaluation of who best can lead the ruling party and the country.

Mbeki’s fans are right: he did have some leadership strengths. He was in firm intellectual control of his presidency. His centrist macroeconomic policies mixed pragmatism and a concern for welfare, to good effect. To attract foreign direct investment, he relaxed exchange controls and made the labor market more flexible, all the while maintaining high spending on social security.

Internationally, Mbeki also championed the view that Africa should be treated as an equal player on the world stage. To show that the continent was capable of managing its own democratization, for example, he supported the African Peer Review Mechanism, an institution run by Africans to evaluate each member country’s overall development.



Advertisement

Zuma, by contrast, appears intellectually limp and indecisive. In particular he has not done enough to help professionalize the civil service or root out corruption. During recent debates, he offered no view about whether to nationalize mines. He has also been vague about whether the powers of the constitutional court should be revised. According to the prominent political analyst Prince Mashele, Zuma offers “giggling affability,” but “little in the form of intellectual distinction places Zuma above the level of an average member of the A.N.C.”

The A.N.C. has not taken kindly to such portrayals and counters they are elitists’ reaction to Zuma’s rural background rather than a fair assessment of his record or skills.

It, too, has a point. All those warm and fuzzy memories of Mbeki are part revisionism. His policies on AIDS, for instance, were a disaster. Mbeki distrusted the science that held H.I.V. causes AIDS, and he questioned the efficacy of antiretroviral drugs. As a result, AIDS drugs were rolled out not in 2000, when they could have been, but only in 2004, and some 330,000 preventable AIDS-related deaths occurred in the intervening years.

But Mbeki’s fans are overlooking these important facts in their effort to undermine the case for Zuma’s reelection. This is not only to mistreat history; it is also to distort an important reality: that no leader has yet cracked South Africa’s post-democratic development challenges. There has yet to be a post-apartheid president who combines intellectual heft with technocratic talent and can also move South Africans of all backgrounds to overcome historic wrongs together.

Nelson Mandela was inspirational, of course, but he was no technocrat. Mbeki was intellectually gifted but a divisive character. Zuma has a charming, inclusive style, but he has failed to develop a bureaucracy that can deliver on the A.N.C’s electoral promise, “A better life for all.” Despite the mythmaking about some of these big men, for the majority of South Africans, the gap between policy and progress remains gigantic.

Eusebius McKaiser is a political analyst at Wits University in Johannesburg, South Africa. This article was originally published in the International Herald Tribune


 
Email this to a friend Printable Version Discuss This Story
Share this article:

Digg it

Del.icio.us

Reddit

Newsvine

Nowpublic

Stumbleupon

Face Book

Myspace

Fark
 
 
 
comments powered by Disqus
 
RSS NewsTicker