1 August 2015
   
New Zimbabwe Header
Ongoing retrenchments good, says minister
Diaspora sends $409m this year, Chinamasa
Job losses: Unions give Mugabe ultimatum
Supreme Court ruling costs journos jobs
Gvt begins to pay suffering former MPs
US to build $200 million embassy compound
Minister Chimene savages Muchinguri
Chidyausiku ruling: NRZ fires 1 500
MORE NEWS
Zimplats in $33m loss as sales fall
Barclays Zimbabwe profit down 24pct
MORE BUSINESS
Mukanya arrives for two UK shows
Zim film festival invites submissions
MORE SHOWBIZ
Da Gama thinks SA will rout Young Warriors
Dynamos coach Mandigora fired
MORE SPORTS
2013 to '15: Two years of hopelessness
Manheru on Chamisa: Devil gets it right!
MORE OPINION
 
Obama, Kenyatta: Identity and nationalism
Atheism: Blind men arguing about sunset
MORE COLUMNISTS
 
 
Electoral pact: Ncube the pessimist Vs Coltart the optimist
27/12/2012 00:00:00
by Welshman Ncube l David Coltart
 
Unflattered ... Welshman Ncube
 
RELATED STORIES
Coltart differs with Ncube over poll pact

Following a report on this site last week that MDC leader Welshman Ncube and Senator David Coltart were at odds over need for an electoral pact ahead of the 2013 elections, the two have sought to play down their differences, yet doubling down on their positions.

Some people are calling on Ncube and Morgan Tsvangirai to bury the hatchet and forge a coalition to boost the MDC’s prospects of dethroning President Robert Mugabe in the next polls. The following are brief statements issued by Ncube and Coltart on social media Thursday.

Coltart wrote:

Welshman Ncube and I are not in fact at odds on this issue. Both of us agree that in an ideal world we should have a single united opposition against Zanu PF but we both recognise that that is well-nigh impossible. In the circumstances we should strive to agree on an electoral pact so that we do not split the vote as happened in 2008.

We both know this will be very difficult and if there is any disagreement between us it is in how we rate the chances of obtaining an electoral pact. He is very pessimistic that this is possible whereas whilst I am also fairly pessimistic I think it is still possible. My views in this regard should not be taken as any fundamental disagreement between us or any loss of faith by me in his leadership.

Ncube responded:

David Coltart is correct. We all believe that it would be easier to defeat Zanu PF if we had a united democratic opposition to Zanu PF and that such a democratic united opposition is desirable and necessary.
We differ only in respect of whether conditions for the creation of such a united democratic opposition to Zanu PF exists in Zimbabwe today and on whether given the objective conditions on the ground it is possible to achieve such a position. I believe that the reunification of the MDC is impossible for reasons too numerous to detail here.

I also believe that given the things which divide the two MDC formations and what has gone on between the two parties since the split, it is equally impossible to construct any coalition agreement that would receive the support of the respective National Councils of the two parties.

More importantly, having regard to where the two parties stand in relation to each other today, any honest assessment will show that there just is not sufficient appetite for any coalition within the decision-making bodies of the two parties.



Advertisement

In 2008 the MDC National Council authorized negotiations for a coalition and later endorsed the agreed coalition agreement but the MDC-T National Council rejected that agreement. Today, I doubt if the MDC National Council would even authorize any negotiations on the matter given the general sentiment in the party. I believe the same situation prevails in the MDC-T.

We are, however, a democratic part, those who want to try to construct such a coalition agreement as might be possible are free to do so. Some of us will continue to focus on implementing the MDC Congress resolutions which inter alia require us to focus on the rebuilding and rebranding of our party and preparations for contesting every electoral seat at the 2013 general elections.


 
Email this to a friend Printable Version Discuss This Story
Share this article:

Digg it

Del.icio.us

Reddit

Newsvine

Nowpublic

Stumbleupon

Face Book

Myspace

Fark
 
 
 
comments powered by Disqus
 
RSS NewsTicker