Court rejects bid to end village headship battle over disputed appointment

Date:

A High Court judge has dismissed a bid by a disputed village head to have a legal challenge against his appointment thrown out, ruling that the rival claimant has presented sufficient evidence to proceed with the trial over the contested Ngwangwani village headship in Bikita.

Justice Sunsley Zisengwe ruled that Garisikai Ngwangwani had established a prima facie case challenging the appointment of Nicholas Vaviri Charamba, with three witnesses testifying that the position traditionally rotates among four families and that the process leading to Charamba’s appointment was irregular.

The judge also accepted a letter purportedly written by Chief Mazungunye disowning a court order said to have paved the way for Charamba’s appointment, ruling that the document had been admitted into evidence by consent.

The ruling does not determine who is entitled to the village headship but allows the substantive dispute to proceed, with Charamba now required to present his defence.

“In applying the above test one can safely conclude, as I do, that the evidence quite easily surpasses what may be regarded as a prima facie case,” Justice Zisengwe ruled.

The dispute centres on competing claims over the history of Ngwangwani village and whether its leadership is governed by a rotational succession system among four houses of the Charamba clan: Manyoka, Mbanje, Jani and Dzinotyiwa.

Ngwangwani, who is challenging Charamba’s appointment, belongs to the Manyoka house, while Charamba comes from the Jani house.

Ngwangwani told the court that the village headship traditionally rotates among the four families, with each taking its turn to provide a village head. He argued that after the death of Tavapa Charamba in 2020, the position should have reverted to the Manyoka house.

He said consultations were conducted within the clan and that he emerged as the preferred candidate before the process was forwarded through the traditional leadership and government administrative structures for official appointment.

However, while he awaited confirmation, Charamba allegedly secured the position through a disputed court order without the participation of the other families or the headman responsible for nominating and installing village heads.

Ngwangwani wants the High Court to declare Charamba’s appointment null and void and order a fresh selection process conducted in accordance with the clan’s customs and traditions.

Charamba disputes the existence of the rotational succession arrangement, arguing that the village was established by his father about 50 years ago and does not belong to the wider clan in the manner alleged by Ngwangwani.

He also maintains that his appointment followed proceedings before Chief Mazungunye, who allegedly ruled in his favour after a dispute over the headship. Charamba argues that the decision has not been overturned on appeal or review and therefore remains valid.

But Ngwangwani told the court that he was never served with papers for the proceedings allegedly resulting in the order and denied being allowed to participate.

The acting headman for the Charamba clan, Phillip Rugeje, supported Ngwangwani’s account, testifying that the village belongs to the clan and that its leadership rotates among the four houses.

Rugeje said he had signed the nomination papers for Ngwangwani and was unaware of Charamba’s appointment until he learnt of it afterwards.

He further testified that Chief Mazungunye had blamed his aides for allegedly acting improperly in connection with the disputed order, claiming they may have used his date stamp without authority.

Aaron Mutamiri, a 79-year-old village head from a neighbouring community who previously served as the Charamba headman’s secretary, also disputed Charamba’s account of the village’s origins and said he was unaware of any meeting at which Charamba had been selected.

Justice Zisengwe said the three witnesses had considerable knowledge of the community’s history, hierarchy and traditions, making their evidence sufficient to warrant the continuation of the proceedings.

“The witnesses who testified for the plaintiff are not ‘lightweight’ witnesses; they are witnesses steeped in the history, hierarchy, traditions of the community in question,” the judge said.

The judge also rejected an attempt to exclude a letter dated March 2, 2025, in which Chief Mazungunye allegedly disowned the court order underpinning Charamba’s appointment.

The letter had been admitted as an exhibit by consent, and the judge said there was no basis to disregard it at that stage.

“As things stand, the letter was produced by consent and forms part of the record of proceedings,” Justice Zisengwe ruled.

Charamba had applied for absolution from the instance at the close of Ngwangwani’s case, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to justify requiring him to present a defence.

The legal test, the judge explained, was whether there was evidence upon which a reasonable court could find in favour of the plaintiff, rather than whether the plaintiff had already conclusively proved the entire case.

Justice Zisengwe dismissed Charamba’s application and ordered him to pay the costs associated with the failed bid.

The substantive case will determine whether Charamba’s appointment was lawful and whether a fresh selection process should be conducted in line with the alleged customary succession arrangements.

Your Opinion Poll

Is Kudakwashe Tagwirei emerging as a serious contender to succeed President Emmerson Mnangagwa?

Related articles

Parliament partners Lupane State University to strengthen MPs’ training and research

PARLIAMENT of Zimbabwe has signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Lupane State University (LSU) to strengthen parliamentary...

Fugitive suspect arrested for killing mom, three-year-old daughter over witchcraft claims

THE Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) has arrested a 35-year-old man in connection with the murder of his mother...

Harry van Biljon retraction and apology to Absolom Muchandiona

Apology and Retraction Arising from Article Published by ZimEye – 6 May 2025 I, Harry van Biljon, an...

Bulilima villagers struggling to access health care, seek desperate remedies after maheu poisoning

VILLAGERS in Bulilima District, Matabeleland South, have reportedly resorted to using charcoal and fish oil to treat suspected...