Cousins jailed 25 years each for killing man over cellphone

Date:

Two cousins have been jailed for 25 years each for murdering Kelvin Tshuma, whom they stabbed repeatedly in the head and face before stealing his cellphone and attempting to sell it for R50.

Nkosana Ncube, 25, and Mlungisi Sibanda, also 25, were convicted of murder by Bulawayo High Court judge Justice Donald Ndirowei, who ruled that evidence linking Ncube to the stolen cellphone and the pair’s association established that they had acted together in the killing.

The court heard that Ncube offered to sell Tshuma’s blue Mobicel cellphone to his cousin’s relative, Tobias Sibanda, for R50 shortly after the murder. Tobias recognised the phone because its screen displayed a photograph of their younger brother.

The judge sentenced the two men to 25 years’ imprisonment each, finding that the aggravating circumstances of the murder, committed during a robbery, substantially outweighed their personal circumstances.

“The aggravating circumstances substantially outweigh the mitigating factors,” Justice Ndirowei ruled in the sentencing judgment.

The court heard that Tshuma was attacked on March 22, 2025, near the Manzimnyama River Bank in the Madlambuzi area. He sustained four stab wounds to the head, another to the left cheek, one to the chin and a serious head injury allegedly inflicted with a knobkerrie.

His body was discovered the following morning by villagers Iris Ncube and Ludo Sibanda, who alerted village head Robert Tshuma.

The investigation led villagers to intercept the two accused along the road towards Nata or Senata on March 23, 2025, before handing them over to the police.

Constable Exmas Zanamwe testified that the deceased’s cellphone was recovered from Ncube, while a knobkerrie bearing visible bloodstains was also recovered. However, no forensic examination established whose blood was on the weapon.

During the trial, the prosecution relied on circumstantial evidence because nobody witnessed the killing.

Ncube denied possessing the cellphone or participating in the murder, claiming that he and Sibanda were travelling to collect money sent by their mother when villagers intercepted and assaulted them.

Sibanda also denied involvement, maintaining that he had spent the day at home with Ncube in Tsholotsho.

But Justice Ndirowei rejected their defences, ruling that the evidence surrounding the cellphone, the alleged weapons and the circumstances of their apprehension formed a coherent chain pointing to their guilt.

The judge said the cellphone was a particularly significant link because Ncube had allegedly attempted to sell it within hours of the attack.

“The first accused’s recent possession and attempted sale of the deceased’s cellphone constitute a particularly significant link in that chain,” the judge said.

The court applied the doctrine of recent possession of stolen property, finding that Ncube’s denial was inconsistent with the evidence presented by the prosecution.

Although the judge acknowledged discrepancies in Tobias’ evidence concerning the time of the encounter, the cellphone’s colour and whether it had a cover, he found that these did not undermine the essential substance of his testimony.

The court also rejected the cousins’ alibis and found that they had participated in a common criminal enterprise.

“The Court finds that they acted together or in concert in the commission of the robbery and murder,” Justice Ndirowei ruled.

In sentencing, the judge considered that both men were first offenders and 25 years old. Ncube had two dependants and had been employed as a driver before his arrest.

The court also took into account the approximately one year and seven months they had spent in custody.

However, the judge found that these mitigating factors were outweighed by the brutality of the attack and the fact that Tshuma was killed during a robbery.

The court further considered a victim impact statement describing the fear and trauma experienced by the community, as well as the financial contributions villagers made towards Tshuma’s burial.

“The sentence must reflect the seriousness of the offences, deter similar conduct and protect society,” Justice Ndirowei said.

The judge then sentenced each accused to 25 years’ imprisonment.

Your Opinion Poll

Is Kudakwashe Tagwirei emerging as a serious contender to succeed President Emmerson Mnangagwa?

Related articles

Parliament partners Lupane State University to strengthen MPs’ training and research

PARLIAMENT of Zimbabwe has signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Lupane State University (LSU) to strengthen parliamentary...

Fugitive suspect arrested for killing mom, three-year-old daughter over witchcraft claims

THE Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) has arrested a 35-year-old man in connection with the murder of his mother...

Harry van Biljon retraction and apology to Absolom Muchandiona

Apology and Retraction Arising from Article Published by ZimEye – 6 May 2025 I, Harry van Biljon, an...

Bulilima villagers struggling to access health care, seek desperate remedies after maheu poisoning

VILLAGERS in Bulilima District, Matabeleland South, have reportedly resorted to using charcoal and fish oil to treat suspected...