Legal Discussions with Vengai Madzima: Flats and Cluster Property Management Issues and Arrears Collection

Date:

NewZimbabwe.com has invited Mr. Vengai Madzima, the Senior Partner at Madzima Chidyausiku Museta Legal Practitioners (MCM Legal), to discuss with us legal issues that affect Zimbabweans. The discussions are of a general nature and those seeking specific legal advice should contact their lawyer.

Reporter: Welcome back Mr. Madzima. This week our readers have asked us to discuss the problems faced in the management of flats and cluster housing. It appears that some homeowners in these flats or cluster houses refuse to cooperate with co-owners in development initiatives or collections of arrears. What rights do homeowners associations have in the enforcement of either?

VM: Thank you for inviting me.

May I start by acknowledging that there has been a proliferation of multi–dwelling properties in Zimbabwe and the problems you refer to are a common result of this increase.

Secondly, the role of a homeowners association normally is to collect levies for common areas that are not owned exclusively by one homeowner to allow all homeowners full and unspoiled enjoyment of the property. Such levies also assist in property value preservation and, in some instances, increase in property values, resulting in the flats or cluster houses being sought after in the property market.

A win for all.

To go back to your question, it may be important to start off by highlighting that residents in multi-dwelling units may have different understandings of their reciprocal rights and the corresponding effect it has on the rights of the other homeowners.

The possession of title deeds by some residents in these shared complex’s mislead them into assuming that they own freehold property, while as a matter of fact, the deed is subject to an underlying document, be it a notarial deed, constitution or some other arrangements which regulate their enjoyment of the property.

That being said, the rights of the home owners association to impose and collect obligations are also governed by these constitutive documents.

Reporter: Are you suggesting there may be instances where the homeowners association is unable to collect levies or charges?

VM: The legal structure of the housing development will govern the powers of the homeowners association.

Normally, the homeowners association’s rights derive from either a registered notarial deed, constitution, or any enforceable contract, or a combination of either, as I have stated.

Such will also determine whether the homeowners association is a universitas or other legally recognized entity.

The same notarial deed provides for the allocation of rates, expenses and charges, making available a structured system for shared expenses. The constitution may address issues to do with budgets, maintenance, security, et cetera.

When it comes to municipal rates, these are statutory rates where the association performs a collection role, that is, in instances where the charge is not directed specifically to benefiting homeowners. Where homeowners intend to dispute municipal charges, they may do so directly with the relevant statutory body and not the homeowners association.

Other levies or charges may only be imposed by the homeowners association in compliance with the property governing instruments and applicable procedures.

It is always important to keep in mind that there is a distinction between ordinary levies and additional charges, no matter how the additional charges are couched, whether as levy or additional levies.

Reporter: You raise an interesting point: how does one determine what a levy is and what an additional charge/ levy is?

VM:  The homeowner has to verify the underlying legal instruments governing the association’s authority to the charge and whether or not the charge came about procedurally.

In instances where the residents challenge the charge, the association in response must be able to produce the evidence, provisions, or resolutions it relies on.

Long and short, the validity of a levy depends on the governing instruments and the circumstances in which the levy was imposed. When the levy is not prescribed in the constitutive documents, it is an additional charge which may require a different procedure.

Reporter: Let me put it simply, what is the easy way for a homeowners association to recover levies in a residential or business complex?

VM:  The first thing is to establish the legal basis for the property owner’s obligation, verify the amount outstanding and the date it became due, and, if interest is applicable, then the interest that may be applied in terms of the governing instruments.

Following demands to the property owner in terms of the procedure prescribed by the governing documents, the association may approach the courts for relief, either as summary judgment or summons, depending on the structure of the governing instruments.

Once the order is granted, the association may attach and sell the homeowner’s property to recover the debts or arrears.

Reporter: What defence may a property owner have against the charges or levies from a homeowners association?

VM: The starting point again is the legal basis or governing instruments that regulate the relationship between the property owner and the homeowners association. If the charge or levy does not align with the governing documents, then the charge can be disputed.

Long and short, it must be proved that the homeowners association is empowered to impose the charge, the charge is lawfully due and the calculations are correct.  

Reporter: Thank you, Mr. Madzima. We have run out of time.

VM: Thank you.

You can contact Vengai Madzima at vengai@mcmlegal.co.zw or at www.mcmlegal.co.zw

Your Opinion Poll

Is Kudakwashe Tagwirei emerging as a serious contender to succeed President Emmerson Mnangagwa?

Related articles

Trump questions midterm elections integrity after previously accepting results

BBC US President Donald Trump has questioned the legitimacy of the midterm election results in which Republicans suffered sweeping...

DNA tests to identify six schoolgirls killed in Chipinge fire

The remains of six schoolgirls who died in a fire at a homestead in Chipinge, Manicaland Province, are...

Government to deploy weighbridges in mining areas to curb truck overloading

The government is set to deploy mobile weighbridges in mining areas to curb the overloading of trucks, which...

Princess Diana’s South African holiday home goes on sale for $9 million

Business Insider Africa Tarrystone Estate in Cape Town, where Princess Diana and her family stayed before her 1997 meeting...