THE case against a Harare couple accused of defrauding former Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe governor Gideon Gono of ZW$137 million has crumbled after they were cleared of wrongdoing by the High Court, ending a legal fight that has dragged on for three years.
Clark Makoni and his wife, Beverly Aisha Ndonda, were accused of altering company records and diverting funds after appointing themselves directors, allegations they consistently dismissed as baseless and driven by Gono, whom they accused of attempting to extort them.
Their bid for discharge at the close of the State’s case was earlier rejected by regional magistrate Stanford Mambanje, who ruled that they had a case to answer.
But High Court judge Justice Regis Dembure overturned that decision, finding that the charge sheet failed to outline the essential elements of fraud, rendering the allegations fatally defective.
The said the pair could not be compelled to defend themselves against something that was “fatally defective.”
Prosecutors also conceded that the particulars provided did not disclose the offences alleged.
Represented by lawyer Admire Rubaya, the couple approached the High Court arguing that Mambanje had erred by refusing to deal with the issues raised in their discharge application.
They said the case amounted to a misguided fishing expedition by the State, enabled by the magistrates’ court’s refusal to properly consider their arguments.
“There is no way the accused persons can be placed onto the defence in circumstances where the essential elements of the offence of fraud have not been set out in the charge sheet.
“As it stands the charge of fraud is barren as it lacks the essential averments required to make the charge a valid one for fraud as codified,” Rubaya argued.
Justice Dembure condemned the lower court’s handling of the matter, saying its failure to determine the validity of the charges amounted to a “gross irregularity and serious misdirection.”
Makoni and Ndonda had also argued that the magistrates’ court should not attempt to revive a case that effectively did not exist, especially by introducing new particulars mid-trial that had not been alleged by the State from the outset.
“This court cannot, by any stretch of its powers seek to panel beat the charge for purposes of placing the Accused persons onto their defence.
“It is entreated to avoid the temptation of making a bidding for the State. It laid its bed, it must lie on it, and it must never rise from it,” Rubaya submitted.
Justice Dembure agreed, saying the magistrate had effectively assumed the role of prosecutor by reconstructing a charge not brought by the State. He said although superior courts normally avoid interfering with ongoing lower court proceedings, this was an exceptional case requiring intervention.
He noted that the magistrate sidestepped the key question of the charge’s validity, instead attempting to redefine the particulars.
“The Court appears to have clearly avoided the issue and then sought to reinvent particulars in respect of how charges ought to have been and not how it was presented to the court.
“The court took a dangerous path by seeking to invent and try to recreate the particulars of a charge as how it should have been.
“Findings of the magistrates’ court created a new charge for applicants to face not what had been placed before the court at the commencement of trial which is a gross irregularity.
“The court cannot create its particulars for the accused to face. This was not the function of the court but the State as the dominus litis,” he said.
Quoting the couple’s submissions, Justice Dembure remarked that the courtroom scenario resembled what “imbibers at a beer hall would say ‘muzukuru wachinja cup’,” adding that such an approach could not be allowed to stand.






