By Mary Taruvinga
THE High Court has dismissed an attempt by a group of war veterans to stop the government’s new land tenure policy, ruling that President Emmerson Mnangagwa acted within the Constitution when he introduced a system allowing the issuance of title deeds to beneficiaries of the land reform programme.
The six applicants, Joseph “Ginger” Chingurwa, Godfrey “Zvabhenda Zvabhenda” Gurira, Joseph “Hitler Bazooka” Chinyangare, Reuben Zulu, Digmore Ndiya and the War Veterans Pressure Group Trust, had asked the court to declare the October 2024 land policy unconstitutional.
But Justice Samuel Deme, delivering an ex tempore judgment, rejected all their arguments, saying the case had “no merit”.
“The applicants are labouring under a wrong assumption,” the judge said, ruling that the Land Commission Act already provides the legal framework required under section 293(3) of the Constitution for the alienation and allocation of State land.
The war veterans had argued that the President could not introduce a new land tenure system without a fresh Act of Parliament and without binding approval from the Zimbabwe Land Commission.
They also insisted that the State was barred from issuing any new title deeds, claiming all former titles had been cancelled under section 72(5).
However, the court found their interpretation to be misguided.
Justice Deme ruled that the law only requires the minister to consult the Land Commission, not to follow its recommendations.
“The words ‘after consultation with’… do not mean approval,” he said, citing section 339(2) of the Constitution. He added that the Commission itself operates under ministerial policy directives in terms of section 297(3).
On the issue of cancelled title deeds, the judge said the applicants were simply asking the court to restate an undisputed legal position. “This court cannot be invited to declare the position of the law which is common cause,” he ruled, describing the request as “a futile academic exercise”.
He further agreed with the State that section 293(1) of the Constitution expressly allows the government to issue new title or leases on State land as long as such actions comply with constitutional principles on equity, fairness and security of tenure.
In dismissing the case, Justice Deme criticised the applicants for attempting to introduce new arguments in their answering affidavit, saying an application “stands or falls by its founding affidavit”.
He concluded: “I am unable to find any merit in the present application.”
The matter was argued by senior lawyer Tendai Biti for the war veterans, while the State was represented by T.S. Musangwa from the Civil Division.







… [Trackback]
[…] Information on that Topic: newzimbabwe.com/war-veterans-lose-bid-to-block-issuance-of-new-land-title-deeds/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More Information here on that Topic: newzimbabwe.com/war-veterans-lose-bid-to-block-issuance-of-new-land-title-deeds/ […]